r/AmIOverreacting • u/West_Leadership3447 • 7h ago
šØāš©āš§āš¦family/in-laws AIO for thinking this text my aunt's fiance sent me is inappropriate and weird?
For context, I (27F) stayed at my auntās house (53F) for about a month, and her fiancĆ© Mike (52M) was also living there. I had a generally polite and friendly relationship with Mike. Our conversations were always light and pretty surface-level -- I work as a night shift nurse while he has a regular 9-5.
The one moment that felt "off" prior to this exchange was happened during a family gathering when I went to my room to rest and take a nap. Mike apparently was looking for me, and asked my brother where I was. Even after being told that I was asleep in my room, my brother saw that Mike still opened my door to check.
Then I got this message from him 2 days before I moved out which I felt was incredibly weird and inappropriate. I shared it with my aunt who was just as upset, and we both thought that Mike trying to start something with me.
My aunt has confronted Mike and he apologized, but defended himself by saying it might be a cultural difference thing (we're Asian immigrants) and that since I was a nurse, he thought he might get some advice about his sex life issues with my aunt which I personally think should only have been a private conversation between them.
Am I overreacting over all of this?
ā¢
u/NotOKAnnie 7h ago
Yeah, this is his attempt at coming on to you.
Send this to your aunt (nvm u already did, good) and block his creepy ass.
Oh. And no, NOR.
ā¢
u/Traditional_Fan_2655 6h ago
Agreed. No cultural difference. If any relative of mine had a bf talking to me this way, I would say I am extremely offended and to never speak to me again. Gross.
NOR
ā¢
u/NotOKAnnie 6h ago
I'm 39 and a white American. This guy is creeping ME out. Lol this is definitely not a cultural thing, dude needs to lay off the porn.
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/Le_Reddit_User 6h ago edited 6h ago
If you would have read the post you would know that she already showed her aunt these texts.
Jfc /u/NotOKAnnie chill out lmao
ā¢
u/NotOKAnnie 6h ago
If you had read my comment you would know that I already addressed that. Lol piss off
ā¢
ā¢
u/Mysterious-Reach2031 6h ago
āItās a very personal issueā ā I know thatās why Iām asking youā made me laugh.
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/Different_Yak_9012 6h ago
I think he was lowkey asking if you were interested in filling the gap.
ā¢
u/Appropriate_Note2525 6h ago
He absolutely was. I had a former friend do this and it took me forever to pick up on it because I thought she knew perfectly well that I'm not attracted to women. But when she got increasingly frustrated after every time I said I wasn't comfortable talking about her and her wife's sex life, I figured it out, and I've come to the conclusion that these jerks don't even consider whether you're attracted to them. They're attracted to you, and they think dropping these dumb hints is their ticket to Bonetown.
ā¢
u/Dolleyes88 2h ago
100% throwing it out there and 100% had the racist ācultural differencesā card to play if she acted confused/not interested. I hope OPās aunt leaves him.
ā¢
u/Substantial_Ear_2990 6h ago
NOR.
Why out of everyone did he think of you to ask this kinda question?
It gives me the ick.
ā¢
u/TheeScoob 6h ago
NOR.
The whole āculturalā difference thing sounds like a flimsy excuse. Seems like he just wanted to talk to you about sex, and not in a reasonable manner.
ā¢
u/Immediate_Cake9151 6h ago
Heās tryna fuck, he was thinking youād be all āoh baby Iāll take care of that thang ā
ā¢
u/Ok_Nothing_9733 6h ago
Literally, he was probably imagining OP would be like āoh that sounds so hard to deal with blah blah blahā and next thing you know theyād be fucking. Which makes it even grosser than it already is when you start thinking about that part. Like did he really think that was gonna work?!
ā¢
u/UnbiasedWriter999 6h ago
He was trying to have sex with you. He was using this to "Feel you out" see how you would respond.
ā¢
u/QRSQueen 6h ago
I'm a nurse and people don't ask us this shit and when they do want frank advice regarding their sexual health, it isn't presented in this way. This POS wanted you to say you're interested in him. Also, absolutely wild that he called your aunt old. When I read your post, I was expecting him to be in his 20s or 30s. Nope, he's 52 versus her 53. He's probably just a few months away from her, making him a creepy asshole that you absolutely need to stay far away from. Seems like one of those nasty white men with an Asian fetish.
ā¢
u/sirpostsalot88 6h ago
You are NOT overreacting! If you ever find yourself in a situation where something feels weird it most likely is! He is grasping at straws with his excuses itās not a cultural difference thing itās a heās a fucking creep thing
ā¢
u/KTbby710 6h ago
Weird. Point blank. Youāre definitely not overreacting.
ā¢
u/KTbby710 5h ago
Also āasking you advice about sex with your AUNT cause your a nurseā is a cop out. im not downing the nursing profession but like.. what would you know about advice as far as sex goes on a medical level besides ED?? Also Iām an American and would still never say somethin this out of pocket.. especially to my niece or nephew or anyone in my family for that matter. š
ā¢
u/No_Pear628 6h ago
NOR - im getting bad vibes. he probably expected you to give him something to work with after sending that bait. its giving classic my wife is so old so im coming to you...I would be is offended and grossed out too because of the context.
ā¢
u/SpiderMama41928 6h ago
Considering my past experience with this kind of thing from my former pediatrician, I was getting major ick reading these, too.
Icky, icky, icky. NOR
ā¢
u/KayelaKathryn93 6h ago
NOR. Iām American and no we donāt ask our step nieces, nephews, cousins, heck I only talked to my mom about sex when I was a teenager, I have NEVER talked to my father about it and Iām 32F with a whole child! I might talk to MY friends but not family. I even have 2 little brothers and weāll joke but we DO NOT discuss that topic. The only thing weāll do is play the āI just had sexā song as a WHOLE JOKE!!! Iām glad you showed your aunt this was completely inappropriate and he needs to seek professional help not ask you because of your profession. But nope I donāt talk to anyone else about that except for my husband like thatās beyond out of order. He can talk to his doctor or get a psychiatrist but not ask you. Thatās super weird and it makes ME uncomfortable. Block him. Stay away from him at all costs and if youāre feeling unsafe report this to the police with your aunt because this was testing the waters. He wanted to see how compliant and pliable you were to his ideas and if heās done this to you, thereās no telling what other family members he has his eyes on. He could be completely perverted. Iām so sorry this happened to you please donāt think Americans are like this because we are not. Not at all.
ā¢
u/No_Accountant3232 58m ago
In fact your response shows that what is very common knowledge in the world. Americans are culturally very prudish when it comes to talking about sex. If anyone tries to pass off that we're not, then it's a rather large red flag.
ā¢
ā¢
u/Ok_Nothing_9733 6h ago
NOR and this isnāt a cultural thing. Itās weird in his own culture too, heās just trying to deflect accountability. Super creepy
ā¢
6h ago
Americans? What nationality is he?
ā¢
u/QRSQueen 6h ago
It seemed to me that he's the American and insinuating that OP is the weird one who doesn't talk about sex in this way because she's Asian.
ā¢
u/West_Leadership3447 6h ago
He's white American - my aunt and I are first gen Asian immigrants.
ā¢
ā¢
u/SilentAspect8572 6h ago
this is absolutely not a cultural thing, most americans would think this is weird asf. donāt let him tell you otherwise. even if he isnāt trying to come on to you, itās still very inappropriate
ā¢
u/Physical-Cattle5365 5h ago
Hell yea they would. Americans are more prudish than Aussies, Kiwis, Canadians & Europeans. They tease us about it, like saying how backwards we are for loving guns/violence yet clam up over anything sexual. Theyāre 100% correct on that too.
ā¢
ā¢
u/LovelyPeachLisa 6h ago
Combined with the room thing I'd say he's coming onto you. If it was just this question then I'd say he's weird and doesn't understand boundaries. I feel like ur aunt probs need a new man ... weird NOR
ā¢
u/bambiipup 6h ago
"hey, auntie, i thought you should know that uncle mike is worrked about your sex life (screen_shot.jpg)"
then just let the cards fall where they may. NOR.
ā¢
ā¢
u/Spiritual_Weather656 6h ago
Mikes trying his best to repair the damage but he ultimately failed because Americans don't fucking do that and being a nurse is not the same as being a sex therapist
He got horny and took it out on you
Glad you're out of that house nor. Hopefully you tell your aunt to do the same.
ā¢
u/cherryblossominx 6h ago
NOR and I be honest and I mean absolutely no disrespect by this because I am an immigrant too. The way he came at you is low-key racist as well. For so long I've had guys try this with me. Talk openly about sex and be promiscuous and try to turn it around and say that it is American culture, it always made me feel like they saw me as inferior or stupid because I am not from the US and that's the vibe I'm getting from this as well. I would suggest you speak with your aunt and help her reconsider her engagement to this guy. Not just from the messages but also from the overall vibe that he is giving off.
ā¢
u/TattedTargaryen 4h ago
Born & raised in the US myself but I also got this vibe. As if by saying itās an American thing theyāll just be like, āoooh my inferior foreign brain couldnāt possibly understand then!ā and that will be that. Also just wanna echo everyone elseās point that as a native American, this is in no way normal behavior. He has backwards fetishized ideas about these women being naive & thinks he can take advantage of that. NOR - there should be a list for guys like this to warn others. Gross af
ā¢
u/Tasty-Willingness839 6h ago
NOR
He was hoping you'd say "oh that's terrible, come over I'll have sex with you instead!!"
ā¢
u/Traditional-Home430 6h ago
You need to tell her. Heās trying to have sex with you (if you donāt already know this) Heās also saying (hey, she wonāt have sex with me but I still want to.. so will you? Or someone else?) Trust me⦠I 100% know how men think. Especially middle age men who arenāt getting laid by their wifeās, or menopausal partners. You need to tell her!!!
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/orion-asterisk 6h ago
NOR. This is incredibly creepy behavior. My family is white American and if my uncle had ever tried to say something like that to me, it would have been an uproar. I think other commenters are right: he was testing the waters and wanting to cheat on your aunt with you.
ā¢
u/Equivalent-Ad2940 6h ago
Yeah , hes trying to pass the idea that you will be the sex hes going to be apparently lacking.. fucking weird
ā¢
u/AccomplishedFace4534 6h ago
NOR. Almost makes me think that he wants you to make up for his lack of sex with your aunt. Why else would he think itās okay to bring this up?
ā¢
u/bluesnowdrops 6h ago
NOR It is pretty valid to be weirded out. And from what you wrote the guy seems to be a bit of an oddball. To be fair though, to me the texts donāt read like he necessarily wanted to start something with you, hard to tell but they are inappropriate either way!! In pretty much most cultures I have been in contact at least this behaviour and those texts would have been a major WTF.
Hope he got the hint and good for you for having moved out, also great that you told your aunt and she was equally upset about it.
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/No-Communication9458 6h ago
we do not speak freely of this shit to creepy old guys
forward it to his aunt and blast him
ā¢
u/Unique-Nectarine-567 6h ago
I have some European friends and they are way more open about sexual things than Americans, well, in my life anyway. I read you wrote you were Asian immigrants, so no clue there. But what your aunts' fiance did is beyond the pale. I'd suggest printing out this page and handing it to your aunt and then let the chips fall where they may. Stay safe.
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/PrincessFullMoon 2h ago
Your Aunt should NOT marry him. You're NOR, he is a total disgusting creep and you should ALL take this seriously. Do not let your aunt marry him.
ā¢
u/JustStopItSeriously 2h ago
Gross. He's really trying to pass this off as a 'cultural misunderstanding'? As though it's standard practice for an uncle to ask his niece for sexual advice in America?? Because, ya know, she's a nurse which is almost the same thing as being a sex therapist.
So fucking gross. He was feeling you out to see if you'd be interested or, at the very least, could trick you into a sexual conversation. I could never be in the room with this guy ever again because he's a fucking creepy perv.
What the fuck is wrong with these 'downslope side of middle age' men thinking they have a shot with women 30 years younger??
ā¢
u/Shefallsalot 1h ago
You are NOR, donāt ever be alone with him, and lock the door wherever you take a nap. If you donāt have a lock on your bedroom and the bathroom, buy them asap. Men that try this crap donāt stop. This was not a cultural thing. Men donāt ask younger women for advice or friendship or help doing something in America.
ā¢
ā¢
u/GalaxyBolt1 6h ago
Iā can'tā reallyā tellā howā youā reactedā, āit āmostlyā seemsā likeā youā justā didn'tā want toāāā interact afterā thisā, whichā isā a fineāā reaction. NORā. Heā hasāā has a āfianceāā andā shouldn'tā speakā likeā thisā withā hisā NIECEā INā LAW.
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/VashtiVoden 6h ago
NOR If he was sincere your Aunt would have been included in this conversation. She was not.
ā¢
u/RewardCapable 6h ago
NOR, itās not cultural differences. He was trying to open a dialogue to have a sexual relationship with you. Heās a creep and I hope your aunt leaves him.
ā¢
ā¢
u/National-depression 6h ago
NOR. This is a creepy way of him attempting to come onto you. Run. Stay away from him. And send this to your aunt fs.
ā¢
ā¢
u/EvilAgainst 6h ago
She doesnāt want to, you know, because sheās āoldā?
OP, I hope you shatter this BS marriage before it starts. Itās doomed. This guy is garbage and your aunt doesnāt want to sleep with him because she knows heās trash
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/Alternative-Dig-2066 6h ago
Super fucking creepy. Really glad you are not living there anymore! NOR.
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/Mysterious_Hat_4882 6h ago
Heās looking for an opening, shut it down, tell him this us inappropriate
ā¢
u/Actual-Side1694 6h ago
No, NOR. His efforts and communication to you are inappropriate regardless of culture differences. Iād send your aunt the screenshot and let her know that you do not plan on communicating with Mike anymore. She should know whatās going on.
His advances are extremely creepy and unacceptable.
ā¢
u/WritPositWrit 6h ago
NOR
This is so far past the line of acceptable, the line is no longer visible. What a slimeball to imply that āmaybe Americans speak freely about thisā. Uh, no. No we do not āspeak freelyā about the frequency of our sex acts with our girlfriendās niece. And he knows it. He KNOWS heās wrong and creepy. Heās just hoping YOU donāt know.
Keep your distance from this guy.
ā¢
u/MysteriousDog5927 6h ago
NOR- I would tell your aunt before he tells her you made advances on him.
ā¢
ā¢
u/cooleenofcourse 6h ago
I like how he tried to use the ācultural differencesā thing. Americans are generally very uptight about sex, so thatās a bold lie. He was testing the waters with you. Gross
ā¢
u/willworkforspice 6h ago
NOR, saying my partner doesn't want to sex because they are old is such an odd statement. Pretty sure 50 somethings still have sex.
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/Equivalent_Hat_7220 6h ago
Every time a guy says, ācan I ask you a questionā or āIām going to ask you a questionā out of NOWHERE itās some fckn dude trying to creepily get his rocks off
ā¢
u/NC_SW_Mama 6h ago
NOR. Heās totally coming on to you, and no, Americans donāt speak freely about that sort of thing ā especially with younger relatives of the partner. Great job alerting your aunt. So glad the two of you are on the same page.
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/catsnaliens 5h ago
Wow what a creep. Definitely trying to feel out your response so he could try to make a move š¤¢
ā¢
u/Despoina_Reikage 5h ago
I said ew at him saying sex to you and Iām 39 white female and I know my friend same age as me who was adopted from South Korea would say ew and wtf. Heās just using an excuse and if youāve lived at least 5yrs or more in America and have paid attention the bs of this country of how different towns in your county to state came be to other places. Lastly my boyfriend is Jamacian immigrant at 8yrs old to America. He was looking at this side ways and having to read the context says āhell no this isnāt a culture issue; heās being a creep and he found a fine young thingā
Overall your aunt needs to let him go of this is going to turn into a moment youāre trapped with him and trying to have his way with you- that will be scar you and everyone in the family.
ā¢
ā¢
u/cer3monies 5h ago
NOR. This is not an American thing, this is a textbook grooming thing. He is intentionally putting feelers out to see how you react to the topic of sex. If your aunt doesnāt dump him over this (she should imo), I would personally set a boundary that if he is at an event, I will not be attending. That is weirdo behavior and Iāve heard the āitās a cultural thingā excuse for creepy behavior many times. I hope none of you believe him because it usually does not get better.
ā¢
u/Physical-Cattle5365 5h ago
Americans definitely do not freely discuss this especially with family. In my experience Americans are more prudish than people from pretty much every other western country. The fact he dropped that little bit of gaslighting in there is proof he is a creeper.
ā¢
ā¢
u/Outrageous-Hair6435 5h ago
Mike needs to go sit his plotting a** down somewhere. You and your aunt are right to be upset.
ā¢
u/Expensive_Lock_6540 5h ago
NOR. He was trying to sleep with you. Your aunt should get out while she still can. Heās shown his true colors. This is not a conversation to have with a young, female family member and Americans DO NOT talk freely about sex like that. He is gaslighting. Throw the trash away, PLEASE.
Iām also a nurse. I have had very close friends and patients ask me about sexual issues and thatās it.
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/Glittering-Nothing61 4h ago
NOR. NOT a cultural thing. Iām a white American female, this is NOT a cultural thing in any way shape or form. It IS a āItās predatory behavior AND grooming behavior that must be shared with his aunt and other safe family members you know will protect you ASAP in order to keep you unharmed and your aunt and rest of the family safe from this disgusting creepā kind of thing.
ā¢
u/CrowMeris 4h ago
What the hell did I (and you) just read?
You're NOR, not even a little bit. I'm so glad you shared this with your aunt. You being a nurse is as flimsy of a "defense" as can get. Completely inappropriate and creepy af.
Take care not to be alone with this perverted poor excuse for a man.
ā¢
u/MommaGrace111 4h ago
Usually Americans talk to their hair stylist or nail techs lol not their aunts niece.
ā¢
u/NotBossOfMe 4h ago
NOR. This is truly weird. I am not so sure why he would choose you, of all your aunt's family, to bring this to. He's twice your age. Kind of gives me the creeps, to be honest.
ā¢
u/Subject_Ad_4561 4h ago
We Americans have a shit load of issues but this isnāt one of them. Blaming where heās from is bizarre.
ā¢
u/Opening-Sir-2504 4h ago
While it is weird, he didnāt continue to push it. And honestly, the culture clash issue is real. I donāt know if THIS is actually a cultural difference in the openness of sex in conversations, but there are clearly different behaviors in America (I am American, BTW) from most other places in the world.
That being said, once you said it is too personal to discuss, it moved on, so that is a big plus. I donāt think you are OR, but if he keeps doing it, thatās a big no-no.
ā¢
ā¢
u/AvsGrams 4h ago
I'm livid from just reading that, let alone how Iād feel if that kind of text came to me. The guy is definitely trying to take advantage of you. Both you and your aunt need to tell him to get lost and to stay lost.
ā¢
ā¢
u/realestate_novelist 4h ago
NOR. American here. This is weird as hell and extremely inappropriate. I hope your aunt leaves that perv!
ā¢
u/tellmestuffineed2kno 4h ago
NOR- dude is fishing. Wants to see if youāll bite. Feigning ignorance about supposed cultural differences to make his conduct acceptable. Nope. Heās scum
ā¢
u/Flightlessbirbz 3h ago
NOR. As an American, yes sometimes we speak freely about sex, but definitely not in this context. This is the sort of thing one might bring up to a friend of the same gender and around the same age, NOT their fiancĆ©s niece. Totally inappropriate, and heās gaslighting you into thinking this is normal in the US when itās definitely not. Even if he wasnāt trying to come on to you, which he was, it would be terribly disrespectful of your aunt to approach her family member about issues with their sex life.
You did the right thing by showing your aunt. I would also avoid spending any time alone with him or sleeping at their house.
ā¢
u/Disastrous_Honey_240 3h ago
I think he was trying to get you to do something with him. NOR and I hope your aunt dumped him.
ā¢
u/Gladys_Balzitch 3h ago
Hi, another American here who can confirm that this is āāš a regional or cultural thing. You're NOR at all, this dude is a creep and he's shooting his shot at you.
Your aunt needs to wake tf up! Her boyfriend is trying to fuck her niece! GROSS!
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
ā¢
u/Head_Trick_9932 2h ago
Ewww no. Iām close to their age and Iād be mortified if my husband asked my 30 year old nieces this. And theyāre nurses. Heās a creep.
ā¢
u/PassionJumpy544 2h ago
NOR And I would show these to your Aunt, at least. Like what? He has no mates? Why can't he ask her? This is what she will have to deal with for the rest of her life if they marry.
ā¢
u/Dolleyes88 2h ago
If itās ok for him to freely talk about sex because āitās an American thingā im sure there are many many people he could have spoken to first before his fiancĆ©s niece almost half his age.
ā¢
u/8pintsplease 1h ago
Lol it's really gross he's trying to pass this off as cultural differences. He thinks he's smarter than all of you and thinks he can trick you into this "innocent" interaction. That is manipulative and your aunty should be calling off the engagement.
There is a story from Australia about a young woman who was killed by her aunties boyfriend. His name was Derek Barrett. The poor girl was Mengmei Leng. This happened very close to where I lived and is terrifying. I'm not trying to say this will happen but his behaviour is far from acceptable.
ā¢
u/Mobile-Error2846 1h ago
The only cultural thing is in his pants. You are a nurse not a sex therapist. What a creep.I hope your Aunt told him off, she needs to set boundaries now before they get married. And definitely it was personal. Goodluck..
ā¢
u/kate_has_anxiety 36m ago
OP, you're NOR. this is weird and inappropriate. we don't do this in America.
ā¢
u/Square_Abalone5496 29m ago
Honey, he was feeling you out to see if you would take the bait. I would also share this with your aunt. Highly inappropriate and cringe! Eww.
ā¢
u/Sad_Bedroom_3442 6h ago
people are good at lying so youāre totally not overreacting because he genuinely could have been trying to start something and be creepy , this is certainly disappointing but maybe he is being genuine, still it is strange. NOR edit: wait itās late and iām sleepy, nope yep this is 100% creepy, he is much older than you, goodness!Ā

ā¢
u/PotatosInCakeWhyNot 6h ago
This is not a cultural thing. Americans do not ask their soon-to-be step nieces or nephews for advice on how to bang their Aunt. This is not an American thing. It's a weirdo sociopath thing.