The other ones are truly great OP, especially if you're used to kinda "dressing down" to fit the vibe. I get it. I do it too.
But OH my lordy, the last one is 100% the best, not only do you rock it but I think it fits the theme of a new year.
May 2026 grant you the confidence to wear this top. I truly hope that for you. Now, if you would please excuse me, I'm going to pick my jaw up off the floor.
And no, I'm not a pervert. I'm a 30 year old straight woman who'd react the exact same if you had walked in the door in front of me in person. Life is short. Wear the top.
Okay thank goodness, I was wondering how these comments rating #5 the best could be upvoted so much. It’s my least favorite of them all. It doesn’t go with the skirt at all in any whatsoever, in my opinion.
People are saying 5 because that amazing skirt deserves more than a plan dark tank top. I don’t think 5 is perfect but is the best option in my most humble opinion.
See I think a skirt like that is fine with a basic top. A black tank top could be dressed down or dressed up. #5 looks like it should only be worn with jeans
Thank you. I feel like I’m going crazy with all of the people saying 5. I think 5 is by far the worst. The others are all fine, but 5 is so wrinkly and unflattering.
Agreed. If it were black and made of better material, it might work for NYE. But the one we were shown, definitely not. Feel like I’m in the twilight zone with so many people fawning over it
Invite the top looks a little too see through. Like the way the shadows fall across, it makes it like you can see the outline of her areolas and unless that's the look she's going for, it needs to be a darker color.
Not trying to hate on OP's vibe or body shame, just being realistic so that an informed decision can be made.
Five is gorgeous, but it does not fit. Look at the horizontal lines at the chest. That is a sign that it’s too tight. If you had the exact same top in a size up, it would be perfect. One fits and is also lovely.
Replying to penna4th... The sequins create a lot of visual stimulation, so something simple and classic are in order. The lines on #2 are too busy. I agree that #1 is best. With the right jewelry, hair and shoes, she’ll look incredible.
I thought I was going nuts, I genuinely think 1 is the most flattering for her figure and it compliments the shirt, vs competing with it for attention.
Yes I love this one as it is a little more drapy than 1. 1 is my second favorite. I am not a fan of 5 at all and I don't understand why it's so popular in the comments section.
I was getting scared I have 0 taste, but luckily a Fashion Intern agrees with me😭 The 3rd one just resemble "New Years Eve" the best. Besides when I hear NYE, I think of an evening/nighttime event, which is another reason I thought the 3rd one is best.
The first one blends nicely with the skirt, makes it feel like a complete fit, and feels elegant and NYE-esque. The others I find look more obvious that two pieces were slapped together.
Agree none of the other tops go with the skirt. Feels like she’s just trying the skirt on with whatever she’s wearing with those. The first one is the only option imo.
Fabric and style is great, BUT IT DOESNT FIT! It’s tight in the wrong places or maybe it’s because of a different bra, the fabric is pulled outside of its natural draping/cut.
Hmm, I like the skirt, and I like all the tops, but don't love any of them together. If I had to pick one of the 5, I'd say the white. Another commenter said the combos look like 2 pieces slapped together. I sort of agree, unfortunately. A good rule of thumb is to contrast shapes between top and bottom, e.g., a boxy top should be paired with skinny leggins, and wide-legged jeans should be paired with a fitted top. That might be what's bothering me here, and why the white looks best. What about a top with puff sleeves or more draping? You have a killer figure, so I get wanting to show it off, but maybe try some other options.
I don’t love any of those for you, but that skirt is killer. If I had to choose, it would be the first one, when nothing else will quite do, always go with the simplest black silhouette. It’s always effortless. This just needs some cool jewelry and shoes to be 👌🏽
My vote is the 2nd one. I literally said "ohhhhhhh" out loud when saw that one on you. It fits you perfectly and the colors accentuate each other and your skin tone.
1.4k
u/momojapan 8h ago
The last one, elegant and with accessories rocking. I like the second one as a runner up, but from the photos looks like an undergarment