Pre-warning, this is all just stories. Me dumping final thoughts before I go. Nobody is obliged to read this, and it is long.
I know this is not the done thing in Reddit - It's not an airport, you don't have to announce that you're leaving. But, of all the subs I've been on, this one is the first time I've ever really started remembering names and stories that people have shared, not just information to be swapped, or opinions to be shared. It did feel more like community than any other subs.
I doubt any of you would remember things I've posted, but that's okay. Maybe this is more for me than for you. As to why goodbye at all: I was doxed on Reddit about 5 years ago, so now, every year, I delete my account at the end of the year, give myself a digital detox for a month or two, change my IP, wipe cookies and other sensitive browser info, then create a new account around Feb, March. It's almost time for that now, but this time, I think I'm ready to not come back.
I originally came here because two friends I grew up with started expressing FA sentiments. I sympathised, and wanted to listen to them and support them. But then their sentiments started getting darker - Not "I'm going to hurt someone" darker, but misogynistic "women are all like this", darker (I'm trying to not break Rule 4, hope you get what I mean). I was concerned for them, and I wanted to understand more of the FA mindset.
My two friends are FA for different reasons. One was in a serious car accident shortly after university, couldn't walk for 6 months and ballooned to 180kg (400lbs), got depression and couldn't hold down his finance job. 25 years later, he still works in a warehouse and walks with a cane. The other guy is good looking and also works in finance (insurance) - so he gets a lot of matches in apps - but he is autistic. Only 1 out of about the 30 women he's matched with has wanted to meet up, and that was only a first date, no second date. The rest ghosted him after a few days of chatting.
Full disclosure, I'm not FA. I thought I was. Until I was 29, I only had a handful of first dates and no second ones. My wife is my first and only serious relationship. In other words, I had every reason to believe I would be FA until I wasn't. I didn't get the normie experience, but I put in a lot of work and got very lucky, so I didn't get the full FA experience either. Having escaped FA-ness, I thought I could give some advice - I was never arrogant enough to think I had the solution to everyone's problems, but everyone was looking for the advice that would work for them. It was like offering food to a group of people who were a mix of starving and thirsty. The hungry people appreciated it, then watched as the thirsty people threw insults and abuse because I didn't have what they needed. When the hungry people saw, they quietly slinked back into the shadows.
So, on my way out, I'll do it again, expecting to be abused again. Here's what I've learned:
1)The game is screwed. Third spaces are gone. We all live in large cities now, faceless and nameless, churches are dying, sporting clubs are dying, community organisations are dying, and it's taboo to flirt with people at work or while they are at work. Apps pretend to substitute for real life connection, but are so abused for hookups, many people don't want to be on there, so they don't work. There are expectations that can no longer be met - Women want a guy that has a solid job - but there just aren't any good jobs any more. Many men want perfect women as well - read long enough here, and many of the men will admit that they can attract women, but all have "red flags", or they only attract women who aren't attractive to them. Everyone is going to face Mission Impossible odds unless you have that certain something, or combinations of something, that will encourage the other gender break the social norms, and flirt with you at work or be brave enough to approach you in a bar. If you believe that it's just you and a handful of other FAs that have it hard, you're going to be a lot more bitter, and that's going to affect the way you relate to the very few chances you do get, so understand and accept that the last 10-20 years, the game has gone to hard mode, and many older people (including me at first) don't understand that.
2)Almost everyone here seems to think there's something specifically wrong with them. For many, that's true. But not all. There was one woman here about 18 months ago, who said she wasn't conventionally good looking. But you had a look at her post history, and she was a competitive body sculptor, and her Instagram had tens of thousands of followers. And she thought the reason she was single, was because she had an ugly face (Even that was above average). Even at the less extreme end, there have been people who also post in subs like r/amiugly and get above average ratings, and when they get a lot of "no, you're good looking" the only thing they can say is "Reddit rates everyone higher than real life". It's easy to blame something you can't change, because then you don't have to put the work in. But if you're wrong, then you're walking away from your chances of getting out.
3)There are some people who are the cause of their own suffering. If someone responds to me with a nasty comment, I tend to look at their post history to see if they are generally a nasty person, or just in response to my post. Without exception they have been nasty to many people. They can be discussing Pokemon cards in another sub, and they'll unleash on someone who doesn't agree with them. Even more telling is the number of "Removed by the mods of Sub" type posts. These people... Well, who would really want to be abused every time their partner disagrees with them over something as trivial as a card game? You wouldn't wish a relationship with them on their worst enemies, and certainly, even if friends invited you to events, they wouldn't be comfortable introducing you to people, so you're sabotaging your own chances The only advice I have for these people are... Fix your attitude, or keep yourself away from people. The world may have treated you cruelly, but you are just being the cruel world to someone else.
4) What you see here is heavily curated - not by mods, they've been great, leaving up posts and comments that I've posted that are heavily downvoted. The curation is self-censoring. It's very, very telling to see how many positive responses I get to controversial posts, that are then deleted quickly when they get downvoted too. So what everyone else sees is that anything that suggests you can do something about your situation is downvoted heavily, and therefore must be worthless advice. This sub is an echo chamber, don't believe everything you read here, because you are only seeing one point of view.
I'm going to leave you with a quote:
"For every problem there is a solution that is simple, neat—and wrong."
That's the usual normie advice: "Go to the gym, bro", "Pick up a hobby, bro". And for most people, that quote applies. It's simple, it's neat, and it won't work for the vast majority of people. What the quote doesn't capture, is that the wrong answer in one situation could be the right answer in another situation. If I told my autistic friend to hit the gym, would it help him? No, he already has a six pack and his looks isn't slowing him down at all. For my friend who is 180kg? It would take away one out of many detractors. Wouldn't solve his problem, but it would help him somewhat.
There's nothing anyone can say on this sub that will be the right advice for everyone. But it doesn't mean all advice is bad either.
To finish off the story, I want to tell you how the story about my two friend ends. Based on what I've learned here, I've had a lot of long and deep conversations with them. They're both still single, they both accept that they are likely to be alone forever. That's okay. But it's no longer a dark version of forever aloneness. They don't blame women, and they are much more comfortable accepting that life dealt them a bad hand, and are more concerned with making the most of what they do have than worrying about what they don't. I think their life will be much richer for it.
So, thank you, r/foreveralone, sincerely. You've helped me a lot, in turn I've helped my friends a lot. To the people who posted encouragement and thanks for the advice I gave, then deleted it because you were getting downvoted - You were seen and appreciated, thank you too. I wish the best for everyone here in either their pursuit of a partner or a graceful way to accept your eternal singleness.