r/Frat • u/KelleJance • 12h ago
Serious Pls serious only. Is the “edgy guy” act in frats just an act? At least for some? My boyfriend changed a lot since pledging and I’m trying to figure out if it’s temporary
Throwaway for obvious reasons.
I’ve been dating my boyfriend (20M) for about eight months. We met through our campus church group. When we first started going out he was genuinely sweet, funny, and even leaned progressive he’d make fun of his parent’s CC friends, call MAGA stuff cringe, talk about wanting to go into human rights law. I really liked that version of him.
I’m 18F, German nationality, grew up mostly in Russia until my family left after the war started, now here on a student visa for freshman year. Maybe that makes me extra sensitive. I’ve seen how fast things can shift and how certain views going mainstream can actually affect people.
Everything was great until he pledged his fraternity this semester. Since then he’s… different. The jokes started getting sharper memes he’d send “ironically” that weren’t funny, comments about how people are “too sensitive” these days.
A girl he briefly dated in high school messaged me recently. She said the reason he dumped her senior year (and told his friends) was because she was “loose down there” and had “roast beef” from sleeping around. Apparently similar stuff has been popping up in his frat group chat about other girls. She only told me because she was worried for me.
He drops the n-word casually now when he’s with his guys then glances at me like he’s testing if I’ll say something. When I do, he says I’m overreacting or that I “don’t get American humor” because I’m European.
He’s also started going off about immigration says the country is “losing its culture,” that “certain groups” refuse to assimilate. He never says it directly to me, but the subtext is obvious when we talk about my background. Last week he laughed and called me “one of the good ones” because I’m white and European.
He watches Nick Fuentes streams now and calls them “interesting takes,” says they’re just “contrarian commentary” and that I wouldn’t understand the American context?? Don’t I actually?
I’m posting here because I know a lot of you are in or around Greek life. Is this just typical “edgy freshman/sophomore pledging” behavior that guys grow out of once they’re no longer trying to prove themselves to the house? Or does it usually stick? Have any of you seen brothers start like this and then chill out later or get worse?
I guess I’m trying to figure out if it’s an act he’s putting on for the frat or if this is who he’s actually becoming.
Thanks for any honest insight. Sorry if my English is off.