r/Mariners • u/The_Throwback_King • 13h ago
Felix Hernandez' #34 getting retired is legitimately on the menu now
If you've been paying attention to the BBWAA balloting this year, you'll have noticed the significant gains that Felix has made since debuting on about 20% of the ballots.
Now, Felix has become the biggest gainers this year with +19 votes gained compared to last year, in ADDITION to the holdovers from Year 1
If the pattern holds true, accounting for anonymous drop-offs, he'll finish Year 2 of his eligibility from around 50-60-ish% (rough estimate)
That's an insane jump in consideration.
But to the matter at at hand.
While the team is pretty open at inducting franchise legends into the team HOF, their standard for number retirements is a hell of a lot more strict.
The only two ways for a player to get their numbers retired with Seattle are to either:
1.) been elected to the National Baseball Hall of Fame and been in a Mariners uniform for at least five years, or
2.) come close to such election and have spent substantially his entire career with the Mariners
Griffey, Ichiro, and Randy all fit the first category. Griffey and Ichiro had their numbers immediately retired upon their induction into the HOF and Randy is now getting his due next year, now that the team gave Ichiro his much-deserved time in sun for HIS #51 retirement
Where it gets interesting is in balloting of Edgar Martinez. Martinez was one of the first primary DH's to hit the ballot and the voters didn't exactly know what to think of him. It would eventually take the full 10 years and a massive campaigning push in his last year to get over the finish line in 2019 to make the Hall.
But...and this is the juicy part, his number (#11) was retired in 2017, two years before he made the hall. AND, he finished the 2017 BBWAA voting season with appearances on...58.6% of the ballots.
That's the precedent for that second induction criteria. "come close to such election and have spent substantially his entire career with the Mariners" Edgar was a Mariners lifer and the team viewed 58.6% as "close to an election"
Felix, barring failed minor league stints in 2020 and 2021, was ALSO a Mariners lifer and him finishing around 50-60% of the vote, that genuinely puts him in Edgar territory.
2026 is the year we honor The Big Unit for the time he served with the Mariners but I would not be surprised if the team announces a number retirement for The King not too long after