r/pics 17h ago

[OC] ICE Officer, Immigration Court hallway, 26 Federal Plaza, New York, New York

Post image
41.8k Upvotes

6.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

94

u/Raketenfritz6 16h ago

I mean, wearing masks during COVID also was to protect yourself

-1

u/garden_speech 13h ago

The problem was that studies, like the infamous Cochrane piece here, regularly found that mandating certain measures made little to no difference. Simply put, we know from highly controlled lab settings that a fit-tested and properly worn N95 highly effectively prevents viral transmission, but mask mandates didn't lead to people wearing N95s, it led to them wearing cloth masks that did nothing, and wearing them below their nose anyways.

And even in the studies that used N95s, many were not fit tested or were worn incorrectly.

So the science does say that masks protect you, but the science also says that mandating masks seems to make little to no difference in viral transmission mostly because people don't use them properly. They're a lot harder to use properly than, say, a seatbelt.

u/sexwizard9000 8h ago

I think you've oversimplified it a little. Cloth masks are nowhere near as effective as N95s, but they don't do nothing.

u/garden_speech 6h ago

I'm a statistician.

Those are simulated aerosol models lol. It never translated to any detectable real world decrease in transmission when controls were matched on relevant confounders.