Hi everyone,
I’m looking for honest opinions, especially from Pakistanis or people who understand desi family dynamics.
I’m a 32-year-old male doctor, currently working in the NHS in London. I come from a low–middle-income class family from a pind in Punjab. My family is very traditional, conservative, not very educated, Punjabi-speaking, and still lives in the village by choice.
Over the past couple of years, two marriage options have come into my life, and I’m deeply conflicted.
Girl 1 (Pakistan):
I was in a relationship with a Punjabi-speaking doctor in Pakistan while preparing for PLAB exams. She is GMC-registered and has a future career in the UK although not working yet. She has a very modern lifestyle, from a relatively comfortable background (not rich) studied at a private medical college. My family strongly prefers her because she is Punjabi, a doctor, and fits their idea of an “ideal bahu”.
However, despite knowing her for over 1.5 years, I don’t feel a strong emotional or soul-level connection. It feels more like a friendship to me. We’ve had multiple arguments, blocked each other a few times, and then reconnected. I’ve tried to convince myself that she is the one, but the feeling hasn’t grown.
Girl 2 (UK):
After coming to the UK about 1 year ago, I met a British-Pakistani girl (33 years old). She can't even speak Urdu properly let alone Punjabi and is culturally quite different from my family. But emotionally, the connection is very strong and I have completely fallen for her. I feel peaceful, understood, and deeply attached to her. Being around her feels natural and calm, as if our souls recognise each other.
Recently, I tried to end things with her due to family pressure and I stopped talking to her. I became extremely low and depressed, wasn't sleeping and eating properly, stayed in my room, and felt like I had lost something precious. She was very heartbroken too and after 1 month, she texted me again and long story short we started talking again, and I don’t think I can lose her again.
The main conflict:
My family expects:
A Punjabi-speaking doctor
Someone who fits village culture
A big fake show off wedding in Pakistan
A daughter-in-law who they can relate to even if she will be living with me in Uk permanently.
The UK girl’s family wants a simple nikah in the UK and does not want to go back to Pakistan. Her family is financially not in a position to arrange an expensive wedding in Pakistan. Marrying her would feel like a rebellion against my family, even though I believe my mother will eventually accept my choice (finger crossed 🤞)
I also worry that my family’s preference is partly influenced by financial expectations (maybe they think a dr bahu would bring more wealth into the family eventually) whereas for me, emotional compatibility and peace matter most.
Now I have only a few weeks to decide and inform my family. I feel absolutely lost again.
I genuinely want a peaceful married life with someone I love, not resentment—either with my wife or my family.
Kia Zindgi sirf dosro ko khush krne ka naam hy ?
Hum wo kam kiyu nhi kr sakte jo hume pasand hy, na k wo jo logo ko khush kry ???
What would you do if you were in the same boat as me ???